Tracking Senator Hatch’s conservative credentials
Weekly Clips from December 15, 2011 to December 29, 2011
Hatch: Essential Health Benefits Will Cause Premiums to Rise, Restrict Choices
US Senate Committee on Finance: Newsroom: Ranking Member’s News: December 16: “There is no question essential health benefits will increase the cost of insurance for almost every American,” said Hatch. “The framework proposed by the Administration takes away the right of individuals to choose the health care plan that best fits their needs. Unfortunately, the partisan health care law is bending the health care cost curve in the wrong direction with more mandates, regulation, and price controls. I will carefully scrutinize this process as it moves forward.” More…
………………………………………………………………
US Senate Committee on Finance: Newsroom: Ranking Member’s News: December 16: That said, let me move on to discussing the nominees at hand. I have chosen to support the nominations of Mary John Miller to be an Under Secretary of the Treasury; Alastair M. Fitzpayne to be a Deputy Under Secretary of the Treasury; and Kathleen Kerrigan to be a Judge of the United States Tax Court.
I have chosen, also, to vote against the nomination of Dr. Henry Aaron to be a Member of the Social Security Advisory Board, with Chairmanship of the Board as the ultimate destination. Dr. Aaron has chosen to spend most of his time and efforts in the past decade or so on health care issues and advocacy. Indeed, the vast majority of writings that he offered in support of his nomination have to do with health care, not Social Security. Focusing one’s energies on health care, rather than analyzing Social Security policy, is not a choice to be faulted. It does, however, give me pause about the extent to which Dr. Aaron has considered Social Security issues and analytical advances in the field over the past decade or more.
Dr. Aaron has written about Social Security more extensively in the past, but having written extensively does not guarantee analytical rigor, or conclusions and prescriptions with which everyone agrees. And I do not always agree with his prescriptions.
Of course, differing opinions about policy prescriptions or analytical techniques and developments need not preclude voting in favor of a Board nominee. I generally believe in reasonable deference to the President for nominations involving positions designed to provide advice to the President and his administration. The Social Security Advisory Board, however, is set up to provide bipartisan advice on Social Security issues to Congress and the Social Security Commissioner, as well as the President. And the ability of the Board Chair to work toward gathering bipartisan consensus is crucial to the Board functioning as an analytical advice body, as opposed to a body where political division and partisan rhetoric are the norm.
Therefore, it is necessary to consider the nomination of Dr. Aaron, who the President ultimately intends to Chair the Board, from the perspective of bipartisanship. A nominee for Board Chair must demonstrate an ability to promote and garner bipartisan consensus. The evidence does not convince me that Dr. Aaron would, as Board Chair, be able to set aside his partisan ideas — and penchant for higher taxes as the solution to entitlement challenges — and manage the Board in a bipartisan fashion that aims at consensus in analysis and conclusions. More…
………………………………………………………………
Hatch Statement on Short-Term Senate Deal
US Senate Committee on Finance: Newsroom: Ranking Member’s News: December 17: “Though I remain concerned with the continued extension of a temporary payroll tax holiday and its long-term implications for social security, I’m supporting this legislation, because it allows the construction of the Keystone XL pipeline to move forward and prevents physicians from getting hit with a 27.4 percent pay cut that could hinder access to quality care for American seniors. For one of the most anti-American-energy Administrations in recent memory, I’m glad this legislation will force the President to make a decision rather than punting on this shovel-ready, private-sector project that will spur job-creation now and in the future. The President can no longer avoid making a tough decision until after the elections.” More…
………………………………………………………………
December 15: News Room: Press Releases: U.S. Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-UT): “Craig Becker wasn’t confirmed by the Senate for valid reasons, and the Obama Administration never should have circumvented the will of the Senate by recess appointing him,” Hatch said. “I would strongly urge the White House against bypassing the Senate and making any recess appointments to the NLRB. Americans deserve to know who these members are, what they stand for, and that they will serve them, not any special interest group.” More…
……………………………………………………………….
Senate Republicans To President Obama: No More Recess Appointments For NLRB Nominees
December 19: News Room: Press Releases: U.S. Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-UT): In the letter, the Senators write that “Appointments to the NLRB have traditionally been made through prior agreement of both parties to ensure that any group of nominees placed on the board represents an appropriate political and philosophical balance.” The Senators noted that the “controversial recess appointment of NLRB Member Craig Becker is an example of an NLRB nominee having been appointed over the objection of the Senate and the result of that decision has been unending controversy throughout Member Becker’s entire term on the Board and, which has undermined the credibility of the entire NLRB.” More…
………………………………………………………………
Hatch Statement On Short-Term Senate Deal
December 19: News Room: Press Releases: U.S. Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-UT): “Though I remain concerned with the continued extension of a temporary payroll tax holiday and its long-term implications for social security, I’m supporting this legislation, because it allows the construction of the Keystone XL pipeline to move forward and prevents physicians from getting hit with a 27.4 percent pay cut that could hinder access to quality care for American seniors. For one of the most anti-American-energy Administrations in recent memory, I’m glad this legislation will force the President to make a decision rather than punting on this shovel-ready, private-sector project that will spur job-creation now and in the future. The President can no longer avoid making a tough decision until after the elections.” More…
……………………………………………………………….
Hatch Votes Against Trillion Dollar Spending Bill
December 19: News Room: Press Releases: U.S. Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-UT): “Our national debt is more than $15 trillion, and unfortunately this bill continues to spend more money that we simply don’t have. Utahns are sick and tired of Washington spending us blind. It’s time to get serious about getting our spending under control so we strengthen the economy for current and future generations of Utahns, and that’s why I opposed this spending bill today.”
………………………………………………………………
Senate Republicans to President Obama: No More Recess Appointments for NLRB Nominees
December 19: News Room: Press Releases: U.S. Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-UT): In the letter, the Senators write that “Appointments to the NLRB have traditionally been made through prior agreement of both parties to ensure that any group of nominees placed on the board represents an appropriate political and philosophical balance.” The Senators noted that the “controversial recess appointment of NLRB Member Craig Becker is an example of an NLRB nominee having been appointed over the objection of the Senate and the result of that decision has been unending controversy throughout Member Becker’s entire term on the Board and, which has undermined the credibility of the entire NLRB.” More…
……………………………………………………………….
Hatch On House Payroll Tax Extension Vote
December 20: News Room: Press Releases: U.S. Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-UT): “The only way to resolve this impasse is for the President to weigh in and force Senate Democrats to reconvene to iron out the differences with the House.”
………………………………………………………………
Hatch Statement on New BLM Guidelines for Sage Grouse
December 29: News Room: Press Releases: U.S. Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-UT): “Yet again, the BLM is trying to muscle its way into a situation where the State of Utah, private landowners, private industries and other stakeholders have already taken action. This type of one-size-fits-all environmental policy may be good for bureaucrats in Washington but it sure doesn’t work for Utah. Utahns don’t need any more direction from the BLM. The BLM needs to let Utahns continue to do their jobs and for the BLM to stop standing in the way of the economic and recreational opportunities that make Utah great.” More…
……………………………………………………………….
Salt Lake Tribune: Political Cornflakes: December 19: Sen. Orrin Hatch is tried of being forced to go through the full-body scanners at the airport instead of being allowed to go through a regular metal detector. It’s a complaint he has heard from Utahns and one he pressed with Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano on Wednesday.
“Maybe I look like a terrorist, I don’t know, but I don’t think so,” he said with a chuckle. “I’m really very kind and loving.” More…
………………………………………………………………
Hatch: Obama is a ‘scaredy cat’
POLITICO: December 16: Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah) is so frustrated by President Barack Obama that the senator blurted out Friday morning in a TV interview that the president is a “scaredy cat hiding in some closet in the White House.”
Hatch was criticizing Obama on Fox News for dilly-dallying on the proposed Keystone XL pipeline project.
“I mean, my gosh, it makes sense. It is a shovel-ready project, ready to go right now. The pipes are already bought. It just has to be done,” Hatch said. “All we need [is] a president who will step up and start to lead and quit acting like some scaredy cat hiding in some closet in the White House.”
Hatch quickly added, “Maybe that is not — maybe I shouldn’t have said it that way, but that’s the way I feel right now.”
The Utah Republican also said Obama seems to want to “play games” with the controversial proposal.
“His environmental extremists don’t want it, and yet all of his union people, including the Teamsters, do want it because it means 20,000 new highly paid jobs, and it also means an alleviation of some of our dependency on foreign oil,” Hatch said. More…
………………………………………………………………
Salt Lake Tribune: December 17: Sen. Orrin Hatch needs to explain how it is that a small payroll tax cut given to everyone for one year isn’t helpful to economic or job growth, but a nine-year tax cut for the wealthy is (“Hatch opposes temporary payroll tax cut,” Tribune, Dec. 3).
The wealthy have been receiving a tax cut for the past nine years, yet studies show that there is no relationship between tax cuts for the wealthy and job growth.
A good portion of our current debt is because of this tax cut. Why would anyone, other than the wealthy, support the continuation of this tax cut?
Tom Day
Salt Lake City
………………………………………………………………
Payroll deal sails through Senate, 89-10
POLITICO: December 17: “I think we’re robbing Peter to pay Paul, and we don’t have any money to pay Peter back,” said Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah). “That bothers me a lot.” More…
………………………………………………………………
Keystone Pipeline Faces Uncertain Fate Despite Senate Deal
FOX News: December 17: Republicans hope that in an election year, Obama will side with those pushing for job creation and approve the permit. Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, told Fox News it would be “crazy” to deny the project just to please “radical” environmentalists. More…
………………………………………………………………
The Top-10 Utah Political Stories of 2011
Utah Pulse: December 19: 2011 was an eventful year in Utah’s political universe. From the passage and repeal of HB 477 to Rep. Jason Chaffetz deciding not to challenge Sen. Orrin Hatch to the once-a-decade redistricting process. We asked our “political insiders” what they thought were the top-10 stories of 2011.
UtahPolicy.com “political insiders’” choices for the top-10 Utah political stories of 2011
#5After years of deficit, Utah is once again running a budget surplus.
#6Forbes magazine names Utah the “Best State for Business”
#9After a long flirtation with a run, Rep. Jason Chaffetz chooses not to challenge Sen. Orrin Hatch for the GOP nomination in 2012 More…
………………………………………………………………
Tea Party ‘super PAC’ going after Sen. Orrin Hatch
iWatchNews: December 20: An outside spending group affiliated with the conservative Tea Party movement is targeting long-time Utah Republican Sen. Orrin Hatch in 2012 for not being conservative enough.
FreedomWorks for America is a so-called “super PAC,” meaning it can accept unlimited donations from corporations, individuals and labor unions and spend the funds on advertising and other expenditures aimed at electing or defeating a candidate.
On Tuesday, the group reported to the Federal Election Commission that it spent more than $43,000 on expenditures to oppose Hatch, including payments to a Utah communications firm for research, a D.C.-based polling firm, an Oregon-based yard sign manufacturer and a North Carolina online services company.
The group is affiliated with the conservative FreedomWorks 501(c4) nonprofit group, which also spends money on campaign advertising, but is not required to reveal its donors.
Ryan Hecker, a spokesman for the super PAC, told iWatch News the group opposes what it calls Hatch’s support for increased federal government spending and support of the Department of Education and the Department of Housing and Urban Development.
The organization is required to reveal its donors, but is too new to file a report. The super PAC launched in September and promised a grass roots approach to organizing rather than a massive ad buy. More…
………………………………………………………………
Salt Lake Tribune: December 26: My compliments for the editorial “Victory for terror: Lee and Chaffetz defend liberties” (Our View, Dec. 19), which discussed the National Defense Authorization Act of 2012 and its provision allowing for the detention of American citizens without due process for indefinite periods. That should scare the socks off any thinking individual, and it will if enough news media take up the challenge.
One wonders why Sen. Orrin Hatch and Reps. Jim Matheson and Rob Bishop voted for it. Somebody ought to ask them.
Bart Carter
Highland
………………………………………………………………
‘New Year’s Resolutions’ for 2012
Utah Pulse: December 27: 2011 is winding down, and we asked our insiders to come up with some “New Year’s Resolutions” for someone or something in Utah politics.
“May Orrin Hatch resolve to just be the solid Senator with wisdom he has been all these years and forget what some are trying to make him out to be.” More…
………………………………………………………………
Founders of Patrick Henry Caucus moving on
Daily Herald: December 29: “Our goal has been to push the state sovereignty movement and a conservative agenda,” said Herrod, who is expected to run against Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, in 2012. “From my perspective we have become a little frustrated because some of the things we have wanted to accomplish we are finding can only be done at a federal level. I think that is why you see three members of the caucus looking at running for the federal delegation and one to be the governor.” More…
………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………
Dan Liljenquist
Liljenquist resigns from Utah Senate, may challenge Hatch
Deseret News: December 15: Sen. Dan Liljenquist, R-Bountiful, resigned from the Utah Legislature on Thursday, perhaps paving the way for a run against U.S. Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah.
Liljenquist declined Thursday to say whether he planned to challenge the six-term senator, instead saying he will make an official announcement in January.
“I’ve so enjoyed serving the people of south Davis County,” he said. “It’s been a great honor. I’ve worked hard, and we’ve gotten some good things done.”
Liljenquist said he’s hoping the timing of his resignation allows enough time for south Davis County residents “to select a suitable replacement who can hit the ground running” in time for the start of the 2012 legislative session on Jan. 23.
In a letter delivered to Senate President Micheal Waddoups on Thursday afternoon, Liljenquist said his resignation is “effective immediately.”
“I do this with a sense of gratitude and optimism,” the letter states. “Life is short. It’s time to move on.”
Liljenquist said he “tried to bloom where … planted,” and thanked Waddoups for assigning him to work on ethics, business and retirement issues.
“He was involved in a lot of things,” Waddoups said of Liljenquist. “He represented his people up in Davis County well. He’ll be missed. They’ll be hard pressed to replace him.”
In October, Liljenquist was honored as one of the nation’s nine “2011 Public Officials of the Year” by Governing magazine. He was recognized by the magazine for his overhaul of the state’s pension plan to compensate for the loss of more than $6 billion in the economic downturn.
Liljenquist sponsored a number of bills beginning in the 2010 Legislature to avoid having to put $400 million annually into the system for the next 25 years.
Last month, Liljenquist was named “Legislative Entrepreneur of the Year” by FreedomWorks, a national tea party organization based in Washington, D.C. More…
………………………………………………………………
Meet Orrin Hatch’s Tea Party threat
Washington Examiner: Joel Gehrke: December 21: “God bless Orrin Hatch for his service to this state,” said state senator Dan Liljenquist, R, who is strongly considering a run against Hatch, in a recent telephone interview. “I was two years old when he was elected and he’s been there a long time representing the state. But elections really are about the future, and I’m looking for leadership on these entitlement issues, the issues I focused on in the Utah legislature: long term spending, the long term trajectory of our budgets, and trying to make sure those issues are tackled before they become disastrous.”
The implicit commentary, that Hatch — a 36-year U.S. Senator — has been in Washington too long, calls to mind Hatch’s original campaign for Senate against an 18-year incumbent, Democrat Frank Moss. “What do you call a Senator who’s served in office for 18 years?” Hatch asked of the incumbent Senator in 1976. “You call him home.”
Liljenquist, who recently received the “Legislative Entrepreneur of the Year Award” from the conservative group Freedomworks, is willing to put a sharp edge on the apparently positive gloss on Hatch’s career. “He’s certainly an institution, but there’s a whole new generation of people getting involved in politics who are saying, ‘where have our leaders been, how did we get here, and who is going to get us out of it?’”
Congress has “driven more and more decisions away from Utah and to the federal government — from 1979 when Sen. Hatch and others voted to establish the federal Department of Education — to as recently as this decade, with the massive expansion of entitlement programs.”
Liljenquist even laid the aspects of Obamacare most detested by the Tea Party at Hatch’s door. “It was this generation of politicians, Republicans and Democrats, that laid out the constitutional argument for individual mandates in the early 90s,” he said, “As states, we deal with the aftermath of these decisions, and in many ways we’re being blackmailed with our own money.”
Were he to run for Senate and win (and he certainly sounds like a candidate), Liljenquist says he would want to lead the charge on entitlement reforms, while emphasizing the need to honor commitments made to seniors dependent on Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid. “We as a country will not survive unless we put Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security on a sustainable footing,” he said. Liljenquist promised to advocate The Path to Prosperity proposed by Rep. Paul Ryan, R-Wis. He allowed, however, that Newt Gingrich’s critique of the plan — that the change in Medicare should not be mandatory — identified an imperfection in Ryan’s plan.
“People in my generation, we need a different deal,” Liljenquist concluded. “I think people in my generation are willing to make that tradeoff. They’d rather have a free country and have the government do a little bit less for them than to be ensnared, entrapped, and crushed by debt. The time for that debate has come, and that’s exactly where I’m interested in stepping up.”
Liljenquist told The Washington Examiner that he will announce his final decision on whether to run in January. More…
………………………………………………………………
Here’s what Utah’s politicians wished from Santa
Deseret News: December 25: Sen. Orrin Hatch sought nothing for himself this Christmas. He respects the financial and fiscal skills of possible opponent State Sen. Dan Liljenquist so much that he asked Santa to deliver a church mission call to Liljenquist to overhaul the LDS Church retirement system.
Liljenquist’s Christmas request was also quite simple: He just asked Santa to help Hatch “act his age” with a bounteous number of “senior moments” in 2012. More…
………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………
Mia Love for Congress
Rep. Jim Matheson leads all comers in Utah’s new 4th Congressional District, poll shows
Deseret News: December 25: Incumbency has its privileges, even in a congressional district without an incumbent.
Rep. Jim Matheson leads all challengers, none of whom in these early stages can match his name recognition or likability, in Utah’s recently drawn 4th Congressional District, a new poll shows.
The Democratic six-term congressman quickly established himself as the frontrunner in the new district after jumping a week ago from the 2nd District for the 2012 election. But that doesn’t mean he isn’t in for a tough fight.
“Jim Matheson will have a lot of work to do win,” pollster Dan Jones said. “I believe this is one the Democrats are counting on winning, but it’s going to be a close race at every level.”
The Utah Legislature redrew congressional boundaries this fall to reflect the 2010 census that gave the state a fourth U.S. House seat. Lawmakers carved Matheson’s current district four ways. The new 4th District contains southwestern Salt Lake County, western Utah County and all of Juab and Sanpete counties — all heavily Republican.
“I’ve never let the boundaries of a district define what I’ve done. I try to act in the interest of all of the state of Utah. I think people know that,” Matheson said.
The poll shows Sandstrom and Wimmer in a dead heat for the GOP nomination, with Saratoga Springs Mayor Mia Love hanging close. State delegates next spring will choose a nominee or send two candidates to a primary election.
“It’s going to be hard fought,” Jones said. “I don’t see any way they can avoid a primary.”
Jones sees Wimmer, Sandstrom and Love as viable primary contenders.
“Any one of the three could win it,” he said.
The Democratic congressman does well — as he has in each of his campaigns over the years — with independent voters, winning at least two-thirds of them against each of the four GOP opponents in the poll.
Love found the numbers encouraging. She said they confirm what she believes, that Utahns are looking for someone new to better serve their interests.
“I just see it as a great opportunity. It’s a clean slate. I get to focus on the things that are important to all of us,” she said. More…
……………………………………………………………….
Mia Love making a run in Utah’s new 4th Congressional District
Salt Lake Tribune: December 22: “I am running for Congress, yes,” Love said Thursday while waiting for furniture to arrive at her campaign digs situated between offices for a dentist and an eye doctor in River City Plaza.
A Republican, Love enters an already crowded GOP field including high-profile candidates Rep. Stephen Sandstrom and Rep. Carl Wimmer, along with lawyer Jay Cobb. And now there’s an incumbent to contend with since Democratic Congressman Jim Matheson last week decided to jump from the 2nd District to the 4th District.
“You can send a whole bunch of Wimmers to Congress. You can send a whole bunch of Sandstroms to Congress. You can only send one me,” Love said.
Being a conservative African-American woman sets Love, 36, apart from the other challengers. “I’m always saying in Washington if you can’t blend in, you might as well stand out,” she said.
But she said that’s not what will get her elected. Rather, Love says, it’s her budget-cutting experience as mayor and focus on limited government and family values that will resonate with voters.
“This is about leadership. It’s not about throwing bombs or throwing messages out there and hope they stick. It’s about tackling problems,” said the first-term mayor who also served six years on the Saratoga Springs City Council.
Love said she is “rapidly” raising money in Utah and from some sources in Washington, though she wouldn’t identify them. She also wouldn’t address how much she thinks she needs to run a competitive campaign. More…
………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………

